3D printed bone models in oral and cranio-maxillofacial surgery: a systematic review

Meglioli, Matteo; Naveau, Adrien; Macaluso, Guido Maria; Catros, Sylvain

doi:10.1186/s41205-020-00082-5

3D Printing in Medicine

Table 2 General Information of the included studies

From: 3D printed bone models in oral and cranio-maxillofacial surgery: a systematic review

Year	Author	Study Design	Country	Domain	Treatment	Target
2019	Lanis A et al. [30]	Case Report	Chile	Dentistry	Implant treatment	Planning
2019	Freiser ME et al. [31]	Validation Study	USA	ENT Surgery	Temporal bone access	Planning, Simulation, Training
2019	Zhuo C et al. [32]	Validation Study	China	ENT Surgery	Endoscopic sinus surgery	Training, Simulation
2018	Bhadra D et al. [33]	Case Report	India	Dentistry	Endodontic retreatment	Planning
2018	Lin B et al. [34]	Validation Study	China	Cranial Surgery	Tumor removal surgery	Planning, Simulation, Training
2018	Probst R et al. [10]	Validation Study	Switzerland - Germany	Cranial Surgery	Temporal pediatric surgery, coclear implantation	Training
2018	Hsieh TY et al. [9]	Validation Study	USA	ENT Surgery	Endoscopic skull base surgery	Planning, Simulation, Training
2018	Reymus M et al. [35]	Validation Study	Germany	Dentistry	Dental traumatology	Training,
2018	Sugahara K et al. [36]	Pilot Study	Japan	Maxillofacial Surgery	Reconstruction and orthognathic surgery	Planning
2018	Werz SM et al. [37]	Validation Study	Germany	Dentistry	General dentistry	Training
2018	Chou PY et al. [16]	Validation Study	USA	Maxillofacial Surgery	Cleft lip and palate surgery	Simulation
2018	Arce K et al. [15]	Case Report	USA	Maxillofacial Surgery	Mandibular reconstruction	Planning
2018	Lin WJ et al. [38]	Validation Study	China	ENT Surgery	Sinus and skull base anatomical study	Training
2018	Haffner M et al. [39]	Comparative Study	USA	ENT Surgery	Mastoidectomy	Training
2018	Jacek B et al. [40]	Comparative Study	Poland	Maxillofacial Surgery	Mandibular reconstruction with bony free flap	Planning
2018	Alodadi A et al. [41]	Case Report	Saudi	Dentistry	Implantology	Planning
2018	Reddy GV et al. [42]	Validation Study	India	Maxillofacial Surgery	Orthognathic surgery	Training
2017	Favier V et al. [43]	Comparative Study	France	Cranial Surgery	Skull base endoscopic surgery	Planning, Simulation, Training
2017	Somji SH et al. [12]	Case Report	USA	Dentistry	Sinus augmentation	Planning, Simulation, Training
2017	Gargiulo P et al. [19]	Case Report	Iceland	Cranial Surgery	Tumor removal surgery	Planning, Simulation
2017	Alrasheed AS et al. [44]	Validation Study	Canada	Maxillofacial Surgery	Endoscopic sinus surgery	Training
2017	Wang L et al. [45]	Comparative Study	China	Maxillofacial Surgery	Aneurysm surgery	Planning, Simulation, Training
2017	Javan R et al. [46]	Pilot Study	USA	Maxillofacial Surgery	Cranial nerve anatomy	Training
2017	Legocki AT et al. [47]	Case Series	USA	Maxillofacial Surgery	Craniofacial reconstruction	Planning, Simulation, Training
2017	Takahashi K et al. [11]	Validation Study	Japan	ENT Surgery	Temporal bone dissection	Training
2017	Yusa K et al. [18]	Case Report	Japan	Maxillofacial Surgery	Tumor removal	Planning, Simulation
2017	Ghizoni E et al. [48]	Validation Study	Brazil	Maxillofacial Surgery	Craniostenosis	Training
2017	Wiedermann JP et al. [49]	Case Report	USA	Maxillofacial Surgery	Cranio-cervicofacial teratoma	Planning
2017	Oscar Mario Jacobo et Al. [50]	Validation Study	Uruguay	Maxillofacial Surgery	Mandible and orbita recostruction	Planning, Training
2016	Wanibuchi M et al. [51]	Validation Study	Japan	Maxillofacial Surgery	Mastoidectomy	Training
2016	Bone TM et al. [52]	Validation Study	USA	ENT Surgery	Temporal bone surgery	Training
2016	Florentino VGB et Al. [53]	Case Report	Brazil	Maxillofacial Surger	Reconstruction of temporal bone	Planning
2016	Kondo K et Al. [54]	Validation Study	Japan	Cranial Surgery	Craniotomy	Training, Simulation
2016	Lim SH et Al. [55]	Validation Study	Korea	Macillo-Facial Surgery	Mandible reconstruction	Planning
2015	Pacione D et al. [56]	Pilot Study	USA	Maxillofacial Surgery	Deformity of the skull base and craniovertebral junction	Planning
2015	Chan HHL et al. [57]	Case Series	Canada	Maxillofacial Surgery	Head and neck surgery	Training, Simulation
2015	Dickinson KJ et al. [58]	Case Report	USA	Maxillofacial Surgery	Endoscopic resection in esophagus	Planning
2015	Hochman JB et al. [59]	Comparative Study	Canada	Maxillofacial Surgery	Mastoidectomy and skull base surgery	Training
2015	Cohen J et al. [60]	Validation Study	USA	Maxillofacial Surgery	Mastoidectomy	Training
2015	Lim C et al. [17]	Case Series	Australia - New Zealand	Maxillofacial Surgery	Orbital reconstruction	Planning
2015	Rose AS et al. [61]	Case Report	USA	ENT Surgery	Mastoidectomy	Planning, Simulation
2015	Ernoult C. et Al. [62]	Case Series	France	Maxillofacial Surgery	Reconstructive surgery	Simulation
2015	Mowry SE. et al. [63]	Validation Study	USA	ENT Surgery	Temporal bone access	Training
2015	Hochman JB et al. [64]	Validation Study	Canada	ENT Surgery	Temporal bone surgery	Training
2015	Longfield EA et al. [65]	Validation Study	USA	ENT Surgery	Temporal pediatric surgery	Training
2015	Rose AS et al. [66]	Validation Study	USA	ENT Surgery	Temporal bone surgery	Training
2014	Hochman JB et al. [67]	Case Report	Canada	ENT Surgery	Temporal bone surgery	Training
2014	Chenebaux M et al. [68]	Validation Study	France	ENT Surgery	Temporal bone surgery	Training
2014	Narayanan V et al. [69]	Validation Study	Malaysia	ENT Surgery	Skull base surgery	Training
2014	Cui J et al. [70]	Validation Study	China	Maxillofacial Surgery	Cranial trauma	Planning
2014	Gil RS et al. [71]	Validation Study	Spain	Maxillofacial Surgery	Mandible reconstruction	Planning
2014	Jardini AL et al. [72]	Case Report	Brasil	Cranial Surgery	Cranial reconstruction	Planning
2013	Jabbour P et al. [73]	Validation Study	USA	Cranial Surgery	Presigmoid access	Training
2013	Li J et al. [74]	Case Series	China	Maxillofacial Surgery	Orbital reconstruction	Planning
2012	Ciocca L et al. [75]	Case Report	Italy	Maxillofacial Surgery	Mandible reconstruction	Planning
2011	Mori K et al. [76]	Validation Study	Japan	Cranial Surgery	Cerebral revascularization via skull approaches	Training, Simulation
2011	Morrison D et al. [77]	Case Report	Australia	Cranial Surgery	Cranial reconstruction	Planning
2010	Nikzad S et al. [78]	Case Report	Iran	Dentistry	Sinus lift and implant treatment	Planning
2010	Katatny IE et al. [79]	Validation Study	Australia	Maxillofacial Surgery	Mandibular surgery	Planning
2010	Lambrecht JTH et al. [80]	Case Series	Switzerland	Dentistry	Oral surgery	Training
2009	Sohmura T et al. [81]	Case Series	Japan	Dentistry	Implant treatment	Planning, Training
2009	Mori K et al. [82]	Validation Study	Japan	ENT Surgery	Skull base surgery	Training
2009	Radley GJ et al. [83]	Comparative	UK	ENT Surgery	Endoscopic sinus surgery	Training
2009	Cohen A et al. [84]	Case Series	Syria	Maxillofacial Surgery	Mandible reconstruction	Planning
2007	Suzuki M et al. [85]	Validation Study	Japan	ENT Surgery	Temporal bone surgery	Training
2007	Mavili ME et al. [86]	Case Series	Turkey	Dentistry	Orthognatic surgery	Planning, Simulation
2004	Suzuki M et al. [87]	Validation Study	Japan	ENT Surgery	Temporal bone access	Training
2003	Muller A et al. [88]	Case Series	Germany	Cranial Surgery	Cranioplasty, tumor removal	Planning, Simulation
1997	Löpponen H et al. [89]	Case Report	Finland	ENT Surgery	Cochlear implant	Simulation, Training

Back to article page

ISSN: 2365-6271

Contact us

General enquiries: journalsubmissions@springernature.com